UPDATE: I've carefully re-read this post and come to the conclusion that it is a complete load of pretentious horsecrap, and I don't think I even agree with myself. Oh, the crippling shame.
There has been a bit of a media tempest in an urban gay teapot about this year's Pride festivities. Who are we? What do we need this parade for anyway? Is there a division between the affluent white gays and the adorable (but do not fuck with them) street urchins that inhabit (inhibit?) the piers every year for the strangely controversial Heritage of Pride street festival at the end of the parade in the Village? This year's clusterfuck of an attempt to move the street fair to Chelsea blew up in our collective faces, highlighting the awkwardness between the demographic divide forming in the New York gay community. The relationship between the mostly white male activists of the AIDS generation and the new-gen genderqueer types from the black/latino/trans/lesbian ranks that are currently screaming for attention has always been a strained one, but until now we have all put on a somewhat happy face together, fighting much larger powers-that-be for several decades.
Now, a sense of achievement has set in among the well-heeled 8th Ave. set, who no longer feel that the fuss is worth it every year. In other words, if we can't bring the festivities to us, we just won't go at all. Collectively, we've made incredible progress in such a short amount of time - it's almost a given that in the next 10 years New York will have full gay marriage rights, NJ is already experimenting with civil unions, popular culture has come a long way in portraying us in a somewhat positive light. AIDS is still a haunting but less immediate spectre in our lives. Perhaps the time is ripe to recognize that indeed, we are all just people, living the lives that people live. Complicated, messy but sometimes rewarding lives. Some conservative gays (of which I tend to find much agreement with) closed their eyes this year and wished upon that star.
What did I do this weekend? I played host to an ex and his friend from Texas, partied like an ageing rockstar, and missed the parade. I am, after all, a somewhat privileged white man with a fabulous view of the city, and my sense of urgency for gay issues is also somewhat muted. Saturday night found us at the old Roxy space, which had been rented out one last time for an Arena reunion blowout with Junior Vasquez. For the low low price of $55 you too could have been witness to the tortured death throes of an entire generation of NYC nightlife. The aging queen of mega-club theatrics was in familiar form by now, re-hashing old standards and mashing sounds together inchoherently with the petulance of a fading monarch. The 'spectacle' consisted of a stage prop wall of hideous neon lights meant to suggest (one would surmise) the media-centric light show of the original Arena at Palladium (now poetically a student dorm). Some reported seeing a show or two (if one considers a Madonna impersonator doing 'Don't Cry For Me, Argentina' a show) but we saw none, instead forced to suffer through a peak-hour 'Peace Train' by Dolly Parton (not live, as he once would have been able to pull off), watching a confused and scattered crowd wander aimlessly in the middle of the dance floor hugging one another - out of misery or faux-ecstasy one was not sure. Sunday was spent blissfully enjoying the soft touch and gentle kisses of my boyfriend, using up the remainder of our own ill-gotten mood enhancers. There was indeed a sense of personal pride felt by us that day, as we watched the fireworks burst over the pier dance from my declasse Jersey apartment with unmitigated glee.
Today, I saw two adorable boys walking across 42nd street, one white and the other hispanic, and I knew instinctively that they were gay. Not because of affectation, but you do learn to recognize certain demographic realities in this city. Call me racist if you will (everyone is a little bit, after all), but one of the interesting hallmarks of gay life is that it forces you to fraternize with other gay people that aren't necessarily part of your demographic set. It would be a shame to lose that unique edge in life, which seems to be what is happening recently. I'm all for assimilation, but I wouldn't mind holding onto the things that make us unique in positive ways, including our ability to love one another regardless of race or gender, forced as it may have been on us.
Although I like where this guy is going with his thinking, I also hope that Pride doesn't become a completely anachronistic exercise for us. In our continuing effort to mainstream our lives, we should hold tight to the idea that the rising tide should benefit all ships, and not cut the ropes on those who lack more immediate mainstream appeal. We all experience our sexuality in unique, sometimes wonderful ways. But we all have secret shames to deal with - sometimes personal, sometimes public (note to Jr.: let go of the past, girl.) Let's not make our greatest shame an inability to empathize with those of us who haven't seen all of the advantages that some of us have been so lucky to see in our lifetimes. Wouldn't that just be so depressingly human and predictable? So I choose to not celebrate Pride this year, but Shame, because it is only in recognizing our own complicity in man's inhumanity to man that we will ever reach a place that recognizes all of us as the beautiful, fabulous creatures that we are.
Recent Comments